How to Playtest Your Game and Get Honest Feedback
By the devbox.studio team at Forging Destiny Studios, LLC
Quick answer
To playtest well, give someone your game with no explanation, watch silently, and note every place they hesitate, get stuck or smile. Ask open questions afterward ("What was the hardest part?") rather than "Did you like it?". Fix problems, not suggestions: players are great at finding what is wrong and less reliable at knowing how to fix it.
Playtesting means watching other people play your game. It is the single most useful thing you can do to make a game better, and it is free.
Why you cannot test your own game
You know where every spike is and how every jump works. Your brain fills in what is missing. A new player sees only what is actually on the screen, and that is the only thing that matters.
How to run a playtest
- Give no instructions. Hand over the game (or the share link) and say "Play this."
- Stay quiet. Do not help, explain or apologize. If they are stuck, that is the information you need.
- Watch their face and hands. Note where they hesitate, die, laugh or lean in.
- Write it down. "Died 4 times at the second spring gap." "Missed the key completely."
- Ask afterward. Only when they are done.
Good questions to ask
- "What was the hardest part?"
- "Was there a moment you were confused?"
- "What was your favorite moment?"
- "If you could change one thing, what would it be?"
Avoid "Did you like it?" Most people will say yes to be nice.
What to do with feedback
- Fix problems, weigh suggestions. "I didn't see the spikes" is a problem to fix. "Add a dragon" is a suggestion to consider.
- Look for patterns. One player stuck in a spot might be bad luck. Three players stuck there is a level problem.
- Change one thing, test again. Big rewrites make it hard to know what helped.
Who to test with
- Friends and family, for first impressions
- Someone younger or less experienced, to find what is confusing
- A skilled player, to find what is too easy
- Classmates, if you are learning in school
Five testers find most problems. Share your game with a link and ask each person to play it once. Then read how to teach players without a tutorial to fix the confusing parts.
Frequently asked questions
How many playtesters do I need?
Around five people will find most of the big problems in a small game. Test again after you make changes.
Should I help players during a playtest?
No. Stay quiet and watch. When players get stuck without help, you have found something to fix.